Caytlyn Foy Bonura, DDS

Caytlyn Foy Bonura, DDS, was born and raised in Silver City, New Mexico. She attended Creighton University in Omaha, Nebraska, and graduated summa cum laude with a Bachelor of Science degree in biology. After four cold winters, she moved south to Dallas and attended Baylor College of Dentistry, where she received her Doctor of Dental Surgery. After completing dental school, Dr. Bonura furthered her education and completed an Advanced Education in General Dentistry program at the University of New Mexico. Here, she learned to perform advanced dental procedures, including implant placement and restoration, hospital dentistry (including sedation dentistry), and pediatric dentistry techniques.

Dr. Bonura is committed to the highest quality patient care. She strives to stay up to date on the latest dental advances to ensure patients have a comfortable experience and receive excellent care. Dr. Bonura is currently a member of the American Dental Association® and New Mexico Dental Association.

Outside of the office, Dr. Bonura enjoys spending time with family and friends, especially her husband, Shelby, and their dog, Maynard. She also enjoys cooking, traveling and watching sports, especially college football.

Dr. Gorthy has long been part of Dr. Bonura’s life. She began seeing Dr. Gorthy as a patient when she was just 8 years old. They also attended the same church. In high school, dentistry became Dr. Bonura’s focus. Dr. Gorthy opened his practice to her and allowed her to work as a chairside assistant during summer breaks so she could see what being a dentist entailed. She loved it! She continued working there over breaks for the next few years.

During dental school, Dr. Gorthy was a mentor, and he continues to be one today. When she graduated from dental school, Dr. Gorthy, Kathryn, and even Jolene were there to celebrate with her!

Meet Our Team

Here at Silver Smiles Dental, our dental goes above and beyond to make sure you are our number one priority. We are very outgoing and responsive and will assist you with whatever you need so you can enjoy a positive dental experience. Call us today at 575-534-3699 to schedule a consultation with our dentist, Dr. Caytlyn Foy Bonura, and learn more about comprehensive dentistry in Silver City, New Mexico.


Victoria Galindo

Office Manager/Insurance Coordinator

Victoria became part of our team in 2011. She supports the front office staff and helps manage the day-to-day operations of the business such as helping with insurance, appointments, payments and financing. She is married and has five children. She loves her coworkers, spending time with family, traveling and shopping.

Andi Andazola

Front Office – Insurance Coordinator

Andi joined us in July 2020 and contributes to the success of our team by helping make a good workable schedule and doing anything else to make the day better. She also likes coming to work because everyone treats each other like family. She has three kids: two boys, Dakota and Duke, and one girl, Dusti. Andi loves the outdoors and going camping with her family whenever they can.

Kathryn Gorthy

Dental Hygienist

Kathryn joined us in May 2016, and she loves working alongside a well-trained team that works together to provide a great outcome for every patient we see. She earned her dental hygiene degree in 1979 at Forest Park Community College in St. Louis, Missouri. Kathryn contributes to the success of our practice with her years of experience, which is very much appreciated by her patients.

Outside the office, Kathryn spends time with her husband, who can often be found in his workshop and maintaining their two rental houses. Together, they like to hike and enjoy their home and the area they live in.


Susan Catman

Dental Hygienist

Susan joined us in 2017 not long after graduating with her Bachelor of Science from the University of New Mexico School of Medicine. As a dental hygienist, she strives to provide comprehensive compassionate health care and education. Her goal each day is to give every patient a comfortable experience and a healthy smile. She enjoys working with a wonderful team and the relationships she has with her patients. She is truly grateful to be part of the Silver Smiles Family.

Her and husband have six children, just like the Brady Bunch. She also has two sweet, goofy dogs. Her hobbies include being outdoors, reading and exploring the variety of art, culture, history and entertainment Silver City has to offer.

sarah day

Sara Day

Dental Hygienist

Sara obtained her Associate of Science in dental hygiene in 1988 and her Bachelor of Science in dental hygiene in 1989. She’s earned special certifications in xerostomia and drug interactions. She is a member of AARP, the Moose Lodge and fish and wildlife groups. She loves the pace and the people she encounters in her work. She finds it very rewarding to see the results of her patients’ improved oral health. She lives for friendship with her patients. Her hobbies include landscaping, furniture refinishing, sewing, cooking and reading.

Favorite quote: “It is not enough to become compassionate – you must act.”– the Dalai Lama


Jolene Peru

Lead Assistant

Jolene joined our team on September 4, 2000. She is certified in CPR, dental radiology and first aid. She contributes to the success of our practice by helping take away added stress from Dr. Caytlyn Foy Bonura and giving our patients the best care possible. She loves being able to help patients out and being around her coworkers, who are like her second family. She is a proud mother of two beautiful children, Jade and Aiden. She is also very close to her best friends.

When she is not in the office, you can find Jolene hunting, fishing and camping.


Adreanna Carrillo

Dental Assistant

Adreanna became a member of our team in November 2016 and tries to keep the flow of work as smooth as possible for her coworkers, Dr. Caytlyn Foy Bonura and, most importantly, our patients. For Adreanna, coming to work each day is like getaway thanks to her love for her colleagues, the work environment and our amazing patients. She is a mother of a wonderful 7-year-old son. She enjoys spending time doing anything outdoors with family, traveling and being involved in her son’s sports.


Angela Trujillo

Dental Assistant

Angela joined us in 2018 and loves her coworkers and our awesome patients. She has a 4-year-old daughter who is her whole world. Outside the office, she enjoys camping, traveling and spending time with family.

Jadin Placencio

Dental Assistant

Jadin became part of our team in February 2022 and is always willing to lend a helping hand wherever she is needed. She is a graduate from Mesa Community College where she played college softball and earned her associate degree. She then went off attend the Pinnacle Institute to officially become a dental assistant. When she is not in the office, she enjoys spending time with her family and friends.

Get Started Today